Are Virgins Overrated? - Part 2

The next day felt like it was dragging along. Paul couldn't be more excited about the night he was going to have with Kat. He had to do his best to keep his mind off her throughout the day because every time he did... he'd pop a boner and didn't want to get in trouble.

Once night came he texted Kat.

Paul: "You sure you still want to do this tonight?"

Kat: "Yes! I've been thinking about it all day."

Paul: "Oh god me too..."

Kat sent Paul a picture of herself fresh out of the shower. Her short hair was wet and hanging down her forehead. Her petite body was teasingly wrapped in a tight little towel and she was biting her lip and standing in a sexy pose. There was a caption that read, "I'm getting ready for you."

Paul drooled over the picture and instantly got hard.

Paul: "You're killing me!"

Kat: "Good. I want you hard for me... and don't jack off!"

Paul: "I won't, but you better hurry up! I can't take much more teasing."

Kat: "Just a little more. Which do you want me to wear?"

Kat snapped a picture of a few pairs of panties laid out on the bed. There was a cute pair of pink booty shorts and a lacey red thong.

Paul: "Hmm. Hard to decide without seeing them on you. ;)"

Kat: "You're so bad! How'd I know you'd say that?"

Paul: "Lol you know me pretty well."

Kat sent two pictures of her ass in the undies. For a petite girl, she had quite a plump juicy ass and Paul felt like he could cum in his pants just looking at that booty.

Paul: "Oh god... your ass looks so good in both... go with the red thong."

Kat: "Yes sir! ;)"

After a bit, Kat was ready and she told Paul to come pick her up. Paul eagerly drove over to her place and she came walking out to the car. She hopped in with an adorable smile on her face. Paul leaned in and held her chin as he kissed her lips. Kat wasn't expecting the sudden kiss but she enjoyed it very much. They sat there for a moment having their first, and very passionate kiss. Paul drove her back to his apartment and walked her inside. She walked around looking at the place for a minute.

"You want something to drink?" Paul asked.

"No I'm fine," Kat replied softly.

It was clear that neither of them were quite sure how to initiate sex and Paul figured he'd have to be the one since Kat had never done it before. He gently approached her and put his hands on her hips. She blushed and shivered to his touch but didn't pull away. She looked up at him with desire in her eyes and he leaned in to kiss her again. Paul loved her soft sweet lips and his hands slid up and down her sides, slowly moving under her shirt to finally feel her smooth skin.

He pushed her shirt up a little and looked at her for approval and she nodded, letting him remove her shirt and drop it on the floor. He bit his lip seeing her tight body in the little red bra that matched the thong he showed her. She blushed seeing the look on his face and he leaned in and kissed the length of her neck as his firm hands rubbed her sides and felt over her flat stomach. She didn't move much, most likely due to having no experience to go on. Paul was fine with that, in fact he felt special and honored that he would get to teach her and show her so many new experiences.

He nibbled her shoulder as he reached around and unhooked her bra, then it fell from her body and Kat's face flushed red. She'd obviously never been topless in front of a guy before. Paul took a small step back to take in the view and his eyes widened. Kat's breasts weren't large but they were beautiful and quite perky. Paul reached up and cupped them in his hands and brushed her nipples with his thumbs, causing Kat to gasp softly. He could tell she enjoyed the stimulation on her sensitive nipples so he dropped to his knees and cradled her body in his hands as he kissed and licked every inch of her breasts, saving her nipples for last.

Paul looked up in her eyes as he circled her nipples with the tip of his tongue before wrapping his lips around them and sucking her nipples into his mouth. Kat released a soft long moan from her lips and arched her back. Paul felt proud and powerful in this moment, getting reactions out of her. As his mouth was busy toying with her nipples, his fingers were unbuttoning her shorts and tugging them down. Kat showed no signs of wanting him to stop or slow down and her hands wrapped around his head lacing her fingers in his hair.

Paul loudly popped off her nipple and leaned back to look at her in nothing but that tiny red thong and he could feel his cock ready to tear through his jeans. Paul stood back up and undressed, stripping down to his boxers. They were tight and short, leaving little to the imagination and Kat's face was as red as her underwear. She was about to see her first cock in person and Paul couldn't be happier that her first would be his. He reached down and gripped her ass firmly and lifted her small body off the ground with ease and carried her over to the bed. He laid her down on her back and kissed all over her body as he reached down and rubbed her pussy over her thong. Kat was already squirming and moaning from all the new sensations.

Paul slowly pulled her thong off her body and finally got to see her virgin pussy. It was one of the most beautiful that he'd ever seen, aside from the hair... it wasn't excessive by any means but Paul preferred a bare one. He couldn't blame Kat, she didn't know and it hadn't come up. Paul wasn't really into eating out if there was much hair, and he didn't want to make Kat feel bad. She most likely wasn't expecting him to go down on her so he just didn't bring it up. He decided to please her with his fingers instead. He reached down and slowly rubbed her pussy in a circular motion and she loved it immediately. Paul couldn't believe how wet she already was.

With his free hand, he pulled off his boxers exposing his thick cock. Kat must not have noticed, considering her eyes were closed and her head was thrown back as she moaned to his fingers. Paul took her hand and guided it to his cock and she eagerly wrapped her fingers around it as she bit her lip. She wasn't exactly sure what to do with it so she awkwardly stroked him.

After a few minutes, Paul couldn't wait any longer. He wanted her more than anything right then and there. He grabbed a condom and slid it over his shaft. His heart was racing wildly with anticipation, as Kat's breathing was rapid and heavy. Paul slipped between her legs and spread them wide as he guided his tip to her entrance. "Are you ready?" He whispered. Kat couldn't speak, she just nodded and looked at him longingly. He nodded and pushed his hips forward trying to push the swollen tip inside... but it wouldn't go in...

Paul knew she was tight... but she was also dripping wet. He tried a few more times but it wouldn't budge. After a few minutes of this, Paul got off the bed and grabbed a bottle of lube. He poured some onto his cock and climbed back on top of her to try again... and still nothing. Paul had never been with a virgin, so he wasn't quite sure how to handle the situation. He felt bad that he couldn't get inside her to please her but Kat wasn't upset. She didn't even know what to do now. They kissed for a while and grinded their bodies against each other. Paul tried penetrating her a few more times that night, but damn was she tight as hell... unfortunately, they didn't manage to do it that night and it wasn't as magical as they both had hoped but they weren't discouraged. Paul and Kat liked each other a lot and they were determined to try every night until it happened.

They still had a magical night, laying naked and cuddling with each other until they fell asleep in each other's arms.

To be continued...